Themes
The following is a thematic breakdown of the novel's narrative.
The Conflict between Tradition and Change (Black and White vs. Colour)
The core of the narrative revolves around the struggle between the established order represented by the Cabinet Makers and Conformance Council who value black and white (conformity, stability, control, and established rules) and those who embrace colour (individuality, change, innovation, and freedom).
The Nature and Value of "Colour"
Colour is a powerful, almost mystical, concept. It's both a literal pigment and a metaphor for life, truth, future, and disruption. Fishwick is a forager of colour, implying it's something rare and sought after. Its value is recognized by some (Transporter, Warehouse Manager, Sky Lord) but feared and suppressed by others (Cabinet Makers, Peacekeeper). The narrative explores whether colour leads to disorder or is essential for a vibrant future.
Authority, Control, and Power Dynamics
The "Ruling Council," "Peacekeeper," and "Conformance Council" exert significant authority. The narrative questions the motivations and methods of those in power, particularly the Peacekeeper's desire for stability and her fear of "ungoverned color," and the Cabinet Makers' self-serving rules.
Truth, Perception, and Deception
The struggles to find an "honest view" of Wetledale. The narrative highlights how different characters perceive the same events or concepts (like "color") in vastly different ways, often shaped by their own interests or fear. Deception is also present, notably with the Examiner's servant and the altered report.
Journey and Escape
Helen and the Transporter's physical journey across the mountains and their escape from Wetledale mirror a metaphorical journey towards a different future or understanding. The act of "crossing mountains" symbolizes overcoming obstacles and embracing change.
Individual Agency vs. Systemic Constraints
Characters like Helen and the Transporter, and even Fishwick, attempt to act on their beliefs despite the powerful systems in place. The narrative explores the tension between personal conviction and the demands of powerful institutions and contracts.
The Role of Knowledge and Examination
The Examiner is tasked with assessment, but his findings are manipulated by power. The narrative suggests that true understanding requires a deeper look beyond surface appearances and official reports.
The Future vs. The Past
The Cabinet Makers try to stretch the past into the future, believing in rigid adherence to established norms. Others, like the Transporter, believe colour is the raw material of the future and that change is inevitable and necessary for progress.
Trust and Loyalty
Helen's trust in the Transporter and Fishwick, contrasted with the Examiner's understanding of his servant's self-interest, explores the complexities of interpersonal trust in a world of shifting allegiances and contracts.